On the flip side, sourdough can be tough to master, time-consuming, and difficult to produce a great loaf every time. When I first became serious about sourdough bread, I decided to enroll in an online
class/workshop hosted by Jenny McGruther of Nourished Kitchen. She emailed daily instructions for preparing your sourdough starter all the way through baking your first loaf. Counseled by her advice, I ordered my sourdough starter cultures online from a source like this one.
I recommend either following Jenny’s instructions which can be found here or following the recipe that comes with your starter cultures. For me, it took a while for my starter to get to where it was doubling, nice and bubbly, with only a couple of feedings.
the starter before feeding |
Once you have an established starter, you can store it in your refrigerator and take it out as needed to feed, and then eventually use for baking. I truly believe for me, getting the starter to a point where it was a strong, active starter was the key to making a good loaf of bread.
Now–I’m not the type to continue with a complicated method like so many instructions you see out there for sourdough. And measuring in ounces with a scale–ha! Forget about it……I like to keep things as simplified as much as possible and in order for me to do that while also creating great sourdough bread, I’ve had to adapt my own way of making sourdough using a lot of trial and error pulling from a few different cookbook authors and recipes.
This is not the best or most precise method for always producing good results with sourdough bread (and definitely not the most detailed), but for me and my lifestyle it works so this is what I do:
1. Take starter out of the refrigerator a few days before you plan to make your Levain and bake bread. Feed it each day. Usually with my starter by the second day it is more than doubling in volume after feeding.
2. The night before you plan to bake your bread, make your Levain. For me, I had to alter my Levain recipe to 1 cup of water, 2 cups all-purpose flour, mixed with 4 generous tablespoons of sourdough starter. Mix all together and let sit overnight. (I usually cover with a towel or plastic wrap) Place your starter back in the fridge.
the finished Levain in the morning |
3. The next morning, mix into your Levain 1 tablespoon sea salt, 2/3 cup flour, and 1/3-1/2 cup of water to form a soft dough. Let rest 20 minutes. Fold your dough over into its center 4-6 times, turning the bowl while doing it each time. Cover and let rise 1 hour. Repeat the folding of the dough, cover, and let rise 2-4 hours or until at least doubled in volume. It helps if you have your dough in a warm place (try setting it beside your stove while cooking or simmering bone broth).
the dough after rising, ready to be kneaded and worked into a ball before placing in proofing basket |
5. Form a ball with dough, turning sides underneath and then place into the proofing basket. Cover and let rise another 1-3 hours. Preheat oven to 450 degrees and preheat a dutch oven (I use a small cast-iron one) that you plan to bake your bread in if you have one for 30-45 minutes.
6. Turn dough carefully out onto parchment paper (you can score the top if you want) and place the dough with paper into the preheated dutch oven. Place the lid on top. Bake at 450 for 15 minutes, then turn the temperature down to 350 degrees, remove the lid, and continue to bake for 1 hour more until the bread is golden brown.
7. Remove your bread from the dutch oven and let cool. Enjoy!
Don’t worry, it’s normal to run into problems and bread flops when starting out. My first loafs were too dense, or too hard, or too gummy. I also had issues with my dough not rising. But the more you work with getting your starter activated and healthy, the more forgiving the bread will be.
One of my favorite ways to enjoy sourdough bread is dipped into a hearty soup, but I also love it simply with butter and honey. I typically bake my sourdough on the weekends since you need to be home for much of the day when you bake it, so Saturdays or Sundays are a usually a great baking day for me, with the Levain prepped the night before.